Ulta Automatic Eyeliner in Black

Ulta's Claims: Smooth, deep colors glide on effortlessly from the automatic tip of this eyeliner. Color is long-lasting and waterproof, for dramatic, attention-getting eyes. No sharpening is required.

I picked this eyeliner up when it was on sale for $1. Normally it retails for $8, for me it is not worth 8 dollars. You can pick up a NYX slide on pencil for $8 which are way better. It also doesn't last long at all. It is definantly NOT waterproof !

  It is retractable, a plus in my book because I don't always have a sharpener on hand.

 It does have a good texture and creaminess to it. The tip isn't super fine, but not super thick either. So this works for everyday eye looks. The color is quite black,but doesn't set and smudges like crazy. So the bottom line is it is smudgy,expensive,not waterproof, and not very long wearing. I would not recommend it!

  (Top-one pass Bottom-Built up)